
( 2 Customer Reviews )
Forwards to the History! January 25, 2013
By Brien Chomica (Winnipeg, MB) See All My Reviews
"Forty years ago we had Mr. Horowitz recording a dazzling version of his edited version of Rachmaninoff's second version of his Second Sonata! My friends and I were bouncing off the walls at University with this old LP. Well, it is time to regenerate and hear Mr. Lugansky's reconstructed-edited-enraptured personal version of the Second Sontata! The more you know the Horowitz (in his numerous CD's and DVD of it) the more Mr. Lugansky's is entrancing. -- The First Sonata of Rachmaninoff is a very fine piece, as everyone who studies this composer knows. Mr. Alexis Weissenburg has made a beautiful recording of this on DG recordings quite a number of years ago. The present recording of Mr. Lugansky is expansive, drammatic, cosmic, and world-encompassing, as the composer intended it to be."
Report Abuse
No memories erased here January 19, 2013
By Michael Gast (New York, NY) See All My Reviews
"Lugansky performs these gigantic works with complete mastery: phrasing, tonal control are all there. Is this a benchmark recording? I don't think so, but it ranks among the finest I know. Definitely worth a listen, particularly for the First Sonata, a rather neglected piece. As for the Second Sonata, Lugansky's interpretation has powerful sweep and great intensity. Still, with artists like Horowitz looming in the background, it's difficult to say if his performance adds anything to the great riches already out there. Not the least of which is Yevgeny Sudbin's astonishing performance for BIS, where the recorded sound is deeper, richer, clearer."
Report Abuse