WGBH Radio WGBH Radio theclassicalstation.org

Musica Viva 18 - Carter, Zimmermann: Cello Concertos / Vogler, Jarvi

Carter / Zimmermann / Vogler / Brs / Jarvi
Release Date: 09/28/2010 
Label:  Neos   Catalog #: 11014  
Composer:  Elliott CarterUdo Zimmermann
Performer:  Jan Vogler
Conductor:  Kristjan Järvi
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra
Number of Discs: 1 
Recorded in: Multi 
Special Order: If we cannot ship this title in 45 days, your order will be cancelled and you will be notified via email.  
On sale! $17.98
SuperAudio CD:  $15.99
Special Order

Notes and Editorial Reviews

CARTER Cello Concerto. U. ZIMMERMAN Lieder von einer Insel Jan Vogler (vc); Kristjan Järvi, cond; Barvarian RSO NEOS 11014 (SACD: 39: 19)

This is an unusual pairing, and it works surprisingly well. I’ve written about Carter’s concerto in Fanfare 29:5, and so I’ll refer readers to my comments on the piece there. The work is not one of my favorites, but it does have striking Read more moments throughout, especially its slow section, which is truly crystalline and ethereal.

But the news in this release is the concerto by Udo Zimmerman (b.1943). Years ago I obtained a multidisc set of music from the former East Germany, and he was one of the few composers to leap out of the mix. He is particularly noted as a composer and director of opera, so not surprisingly this piece has a strong lyric voice and a dramatic profile. According to the notes, its solo line is a series of “private settings” of texts chosen by the composer, which helps to create the natural, flowing, and impassioned melodic writing. (The subtitle is “Songs from an Island.”) The piece is basically tonal (the notes say that most is in A Minor), and the orchestral accompaniment—which slowly emerges from miniscule interventions to full tutti over its course—is composed mostly of canons, which create a textural river on which the soloist floats. There is one section of extended fast music (the penultimate of five movements), but the overall tone of the work is contemplative. To some extent its language strikes me as though it could be from a mid-20th-century minor master, such as Martin or Martin?. But the textural, static, and neo-tonal aspects of the piece make it very much postmodern, or at least not reactionary (though the annotator still seems somewhat baffled by it, calling it “meandering”; I suppose something as beautiful as this—and it is—is still suspect in some circles).

The Carter is brilliantly performed, but I still prefer the recording I reviewed earlier, featuring Fred Sherry as soloist with Oliver Knussen and the London Sinfonietta. What’s missing for me in the recording under review is the sense of quicksilver wit that’s the distinguishing characteristic of Carter’s “late-late” music. The Bavarians play it all just a little too smoothly and seriously, when it needs to be both more light and on-the-edge.

This is an SACD surround-sound release, and the sound is great, even when played in traditional stereo (my setup, though I do have an SACD player). The duration is a little short, and if you want the Carter I’d urge you to go to Bridge 9184, which includes Dialogues for piano and orchestra, the ravishing Boston Concerto, and the ASKO Concerto (the composer’s “Brandenburg”)—the whole disc is a stunning collection. But the Zimmerman is worthy of attention.

FANFARE: Robert Carl
Read less

Works on This Recording

Concerto for Cello by Elliott Carter
Performer:  Jan Vogler (Cello)
Conductor:  Kristjan Järvi
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra
Period: 20th Century 
Written: 2001; USA 
Concerto for Cello "Lieder von einer Insel" by Udo Zimmermann
Performer:  Jan Vogler (Cello)
Conductor:  Kristjan Järvi
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra
Written: 2009 

Customer Reviews

Be the first to review this title
Review This Title