Notes and Editorial Reviews
An essential part of my Glass collection and an obvious choice for those who don’t know Glass well.
This fantastic new Philip Glass album features two of the composer’s best instrumental scores. The soundtrack to
The Hours has here been arranged by pianist Michael Riesman into a piano concerto, with brief orchestral introduction and outer movements which build to climaxes of real emotional power. As a concerto, it’s terrific, something any fan of minimalism should appreciate. There is a sense of dramatic momentum which is remarkable given that the piece was originally incidental music to a film. One shouldn’t be surprised by Riesman’s authenticity as an arranger or effectiveness as a pianist: he has arranged
for Glass many times in the past, joined the Philip Glass Ensemble in 1974, and produced the original soundtrack to
The Symphony No. 3 has now received three major recordings, and it fully deserves the attention. The first movement makes an enigmatic introduction, but the real genius lies in the work’s second half. Before a finale which absolutely screams James Bond thriller music we have a ten-minute slow movement of staggering beauty. It’s a black pearl, which I’ve sometimes referred to as Pachelbel’s
Canon’s evil twin or spiritual opposite. From a beginning of a few repeated chords for violas and cellos, Glass adds new ideas in careful layers: underpinning double bass and then one violin, two violins, all the violins blooming together in slow motion. This is one of my favorite moments from any living composers. If all the music Philip Glass ever wrote was in a burning building and I could only save one thing, I would instinctively reach for the slow movement of the Third Symphony.
As I said, the symphony’s now appeared on three discs; Stuttgart Chamber Orchestra with Dennis Russell Davies, Bournemouth Symphony with Marin Alsop, and this one. In some ways the Manitoba Chamber Orchestra’s performance is the one to get: it’s more sharply etched than Bournemouth/Alsop, more closely miked and with a properly-sized chamber orchestra that brings every line into close focus. Anne Manson conducts like an expert. Russell Davies is the other chamber orchestra recording, and its first movement is more pointed and assertive, but it pretty clearly cedes to this newcomer in the two last parts, which are also my two favorites: the sharp detailing of the new recording really pays off, as does the strong drive Manson brings to the finale.
Only after I’d listened several times did I realize this was a live concert broadcast. Now my hat is off to the Manitoba Chamber Orchestra, truly an unlikely ensemble to play this music so incredibly well, and I have to give this the highest possible praise. This is now an essential part of my Philip Glass collection. This is the kind of album that can win converts over to a great composer.
-- Brian Reinhart, MusicWeb International
Works on This Recording
The Hours by Philip Glass
Michael Riesman (Keyboards)
Manitoba Chamber Orchestra
Written: 2002; United States
Symphony no 3 by Philip Glass
Manitoba Chamber Orchestra
Period: 20th Century
Written: 1995; USA
Be the first to review this title