
Also available: Sibelius: Symphonies No 2 & 5 / Vänskä, Minnesota
( 2 Customer Reviews )
Stunning Sibelius from Minnesota April 2, 2013
By W. Hecht (Exton, PA) See All My Reviews
"The Sibelius 4th doesn't enjoy the great popularity of the 2nd and 5th (also available in a fine coupling from these same forces), and in fact many listeners find it hard going. Count me as part of the minority that hears the 4th as the absolute pinnacle of Sibelius' work. Spare, uncompromising, bleak, unconsoling, and desolate are just a few of the adjectives used by program annotator Robert Layton in his description of the piece, which was written by Sibelius following a battle with cancer. Each of these descriptors conveys a piece of the truth, but I'll borrow again from Mr. Layton for the words I find most apt: profoundly individual and deeply felt. This music provides a rare view deep into the heart and mind of a great composer, and Maestro Vanska and his Minnesotans rise magnificently to all of its challenges. This is the greatest 4th I've ever heard, live or recorded. The 1st is hardly lacking for fine recordings and this one holds its own well in the proverbial crowded field, but it's for the 4th that this disc must be heard. In terms of sonics BIS' latest recordings from Minnesota are now among the label's very considerable best, particularly in multichannel sacd mode."
Report Abuse
IIt is great! March 26, 2013
By David Blatchford (Mill Valley, CA) See All My Reviews
"I LOVE Sibelius!"
Report Abuse