WGBH Radio WGBH Radio theclassicalstation.org

Verdi: Il Trovatore / Giulini, Domingo, Plowright

Release Date: 11/21/1989 
Label:  Deutsche Grammophon   Catalog #: 423858   Spars Code: DDD 
Composer:  Giuseppe Verdi
Performer:  Brigitte FassbaenderPlacido DomingoYevgeny NesterenkoGiorgio Zancanaro,   ... 
Conductor:  Carlo Maria Giulini
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Santa Cecilia Academy Rome ChorusSanta Cecilia Academy Rome Orchestra
Number of Discs: 2 
Recorded in: Stereo 
In Stock: Usually ships in 24 hours.  
On sale! $49.99
ArkivCD  $41.99
In Stock

This CD is reissued by ArkivMusic.

Notes and Editorial Reviews

...Domingo's Manrico is a virtually faultless performance that I don't expect to hear bettered on record, more refined and subtler than his account of the role in the...Mehta/RCA set. He is now the epitome of the upright, heroic lover, his key recitative before "Ah, si, ben mio" phrased with aristocratic style and the aria itself a lesson in legato... His Leonora, Rosalind Plowright sings all her music virtually as written, including cadenzas, and encompasses almost everything with technical aplomb. The voice expands, as in the theatre, grandly at the top, while the dark timbre at the bottom is most telling. She is also capable of a floating line as both her arias indicate, and yet copes easily with the colorature of this tricky Read more role...

-- Gramophone

To even recommend a recording of Il trovatore, let alone say that one is an irreplaceable classic, is sometimes to invite invectives on your head that you would rather not receive. Passions run high in this most passionate of operatic potboilers, and indeed, one wonders if Il trovatore even registers on serious musicians’ radar as a great work; yet even so stringent a critic as George Bernard Shaw, who often took Verdi to task for writing music that was placed too high in the voice and therefore too difficult to sing comfortably, not only loved this opera but sang bits of it (accompanying himself on the piano) into his senior years.

Of course, the greatest obstacle to appreciating Trovatore as a great work is the plot. Taken from a sensational pop novel of the time and then absurdly reduced in the libretto by Cammarano, what reached the stage really didn’t please Verdi dramatically and left audiences either scratching their heads or laughing. Yet captain of the guard Ferrando does a fair job of explaining the pre-history of what you are about to see and hear; after all, this isn’t Goethe or Schiller. It’s your typical revenge-oriented love triangle with a crazed gypsy woman thrown in for local color. What kept this opera on the boards for nearly two centuries, and still keeps it there, is the extraordinarily high quality of the music. It is not only tuneful in the best Verdian tradition, but inventive and well composed. There are too many examples to give, but the opening scene for the soprano, the act I and act II/scene 1 finales, and the long duets between Azucena and Manrico (act II) and between Leonora and Count di Luna (act IV) are masterly by any measurement.

But then we come to how you want your Trovatore performed, and most people want it loud, fast, and raucous, with plenty of high notes (even extra ones not written in the score) thrown in and held for as long as the singers have breath to do so. As a result, the late Franco Corelli is normally the Manrico of choice—that is, if you are not a fan of Mario del Monaco or Kurt Baum. The Callas clique always stumps for her recording, which is in fact one of the very best except for Giuseppe di Stefano, who literally ruins the performance with his lumpy phrasing of both “Ah si, ben mio” and “Di quella pira.” (In my view, if you’ve ruined “Di quella pira,” you’ve pretty much ruined the performance.) And I, for one, want to hear all the trills that Verdi wrote into the score because they’re interesting and add to both the musical value and the elegance of the artists. These include not only the obvious moments, such as the soprano’s two arias and “Ah si, ben mio,” but also Ferrando’s opening scene, Manrico’s “Deserto sulla terra,” and Azucena’s “Stride la vampa,” which calls for no fewer than 20 trills. By the same token, I also want to hear all the trills that Wagner wrote into Brünnhilde’s music for Walküre and Siegfried, as well as the written trills for Magdalena, Walther, and Hans Sachs in Die Meistersinger. Just call me a tick for trills.

When this recording first appeared in 1981, it garnered some glorious reviews, particularly from British critics who adored Giulini much more than Americans did, but left Trovatore nuts scratching their heads. So much of this performance is slower than we are used to, which was a Giulini specialty, but in this case he claimed that he found all these slower tempos (and bits of the music not previously recorded) in Verdi’s manuscript. The slower tempos give the singers the chance to sing those trills, and they all give it the old college try. Although Domingo really only produces a couple of flutters in “Deserto sulla terra,” and one flutter and one real trill in “Ah si, ben mio,” at least he is trying to do so. Everyone else sings all of their trills as written, with excellent results.

In addition, Giulini’s slower pace brings out the tragedy of the opera better than anyone else with the exception of Karajan (with Callas). If you take the plot at least somewhat seriously there is one thing you will grasp, and that is that both Azucena and the Count are insane and must be played that way. Sadly, to my knowledge no baritone ever played di Luna as really insane except Leonard Warren, who did it twice (1952 and 1959), and in the second recording he was not only more dramatic but had a wonderful soprano to respond to his acting in Leontyne Price, but otherwise that second recording is very dull. Here, Zancanaro gives us the usual aggressive, angry di Luna, and it suffices. More interestingly, and not necessarily to my liking, Fassbaender’s Azucena does not sound crazed but simply like an overly concerned mother trying to protect her “son” (Manrico), who is really the Count’s brother, but at least she gives us an interpretation of the role. Once you move away from Fedora Barbieri (with Milanov in 1952 and Callas in 1956), you pretty much leave the concept of a crazed Azucena, mostly because everyone else just sang the part straight with no dramatic accents at all (particularly Fiorenza Cossotto, who had a gold-plated voice but zero acting ability).

By employing slower tempos in such scenes as “Mal reggendo” through “Condetta all’era in ceppi” (act II) and even “Di quella pira,” Giulini is able to tease the listener more familiar with rattletrap run-throughs of the score with his more musical and dramatic reading. Manrico has only two high Cs in the latter scene, and the second one (on the final “All’armi”) is cut off quickly on the syllable “-mi.” There are no high notes for either soprano or tenor at the end of act I (“Di geloso amor”) or for soprano or baritone at the end of “Vivra! Contendre il giublio” (act IV), which is bound to disappoint the high-note maniacs among listeners. But what fails to boil the blood succeeds in delineating Verdi’s and Piave’s dark musical drama. (Note, for instance, the preponderance of minor keys in this music, far more than one may remember from casual listening to other recordings.)

Do I wish that the Callas-Karajan recording had a better tenor? Of course I do. If they had, that would be my first choice. But they didn’t, so here we are with Giulini and company. Of course, if you can suffer through di Stefano’s loud, graceless singing better than I can, you may safely ignore this recommendation and head for that recording, but I for one want a Manrico who can sing all of his music properly, so this is the Trovatore for me.

-- Lynn René Bayley, FANFARE
reviewing this title reissued as DG 4775915 Read less

Works on This Recording

Il trovatore by Giuseppe Verdi
Performer:  Brigitte Fassbaender (Mezzo Soprano), Placido Domingo (Tenor), Yevgeny Nesterenko (Bass),
Giorgio Zancanaro (Baritone), Rosalind Plowright (Soprano), Anna di Stasio (Mezzo Soprano),
Walter Gullino (Tenor), Alfredo Giacomotti (Bass), Aldo Verrecchia (Tenor)
Conductor:  Carlo Maria Giulini
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Santa Cecilia Academy Rome Chorus,  Santa Cecilia Academy Rome Orchestra
Period: Romantic 
Written: 1853; Italy 
Language: Italian 

Customer Reviews

Be the first to review this title
Review This Title