Notes and Editorial Reviews
A few decades ago, Franck’s Symphony in D minor was standard repertoire, and every major conductor recorded it. Now, the work’s high romantic sentimentality seems to have fallen out of fashion, and new releases are far less common. Interpretations run the gamut from reasonably strict and “classical”, to totally demented (think: Stokowski). Monteux’s falls decidedly into the “classical” category, but never to the detriment of expressivity.
Consider how he handles the luscious second subject of the first movement, with a singing tone and real urgency, the ensuing accelerando done with passion, excitement, and yes, taste. The Chicago Symphony plays gloriously (this was the Reiner era, let’s not forget), responding to Monteux’s
every perfectly judged nuance. It has become fashionable lately to disparage this performance, in addition to dogging the work, but as Tovey once wrote, “All’s not false that’s taught in the public schools.” This recording was the best in its day, both interpretively and sonically, and so it remains 50 years on.
The coupling of Pétrouchka might seem odd–there’s only so much Monteux material available in stereo to RCA, but it’s equally wonderful. Indeed, if I had to choose a single CD to represent the conductor’s art at its best, this would probably be the one. Again, he has a great orchestra at his disposal, one fully at home in the idiom, and he leads a performance at once lovingly detailed but also brilliant and glittering. In the Danse Russe Monteux captures the music’s mechanical, cartoonish qualities to perfection, while the folk dances in the concluding tableau have all the rhythmic bounce and gaiety that one could ask. The sonics are superb even by modern standards. What a joy this disc is!
-- David Hurwitz, ClassicsToday.com
Works on This Recording
Symphony in D minor, M 48 by César Franck
Chicago Symphony Orchestra
Written: 1886-1888; France
Date of Recording: 01/07/1961
Venue: Orchestra Hall, Chicago, Illinois
Length: 39 Minutes 1 Secs.
Pétrouchka by Igor Stravinsky
Bernard Zighera (Piano)
Boston Symphony Orchestra
Period: 20th Century
Date of Recording: 01/1959
Venue: Symphony Hall, Boston, Massachusetts
Length: 34 Minutes 53 Secs.
Notes: Composition written: Switzerland (1911).
Composition revised: 1947.
Scene I: The Shrove-Tide Fair: Vivace
Scene I: The Shrove-Tide Fair: The Magic Trick
Scene I: The Shrove-Tide Fair: Russian Dance
Scene II: Petrouchka's Room
Scene III: The Moor's Room: Feroce stringendo
Scene III: The Moor's Room: Dance of the Ballerina
Scene III: The Moor's Room: Valse
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Con moto
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Wet-Nurses' Dance
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Peasant with Bear
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Gypsies
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Dance of the Coachmen
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Masqueraders
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Scuffle
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Death of Petrouchka
Scene IV: The Fair Toward Evening: Petrouchka's Ghost
Be the first to review this title