Notes and Editorial Reviews
I know nothing of the method by which Ronald Corp composes but, as I implied in my review of his symphony and piano concerto, the music always sounds as if it flows naturally from him and he simply has to write it down. Perhaps this derives from the fact that, as a small child - as he reveals in his liner notes - he composed before he could really read or write music. So many composers seem hidebound by the writing of notes on the page and working out sequentially where to go next almost solely on what they see rather than hear.
Songs are conceived in a rather different way because an existing text is the starting point; but words can suggest music too if read with imagination, and Corp’s remarkable achievement here
is that his settings, often of all-too-familiar poems, seem absolutely ‘right’ – and genuinely singable yet uninfluenced by existing settings of the same words by other composers. He understands the voice very well.
And yet Corp is not a revolutionary composer – evolutionary might be a more apt description. Although his concept of an individual poem may differ from other composers’ interpretations, Corp’s style acknowledges his debt particularly to those composers of the so-called English Musical Renaissance. I hear Parry, Quilter and Vaughan Williams in particular, but as accents of a distinctive voice of his own.
Corp has composed prolifically, so although this is the first time any of his songs has been commercially recorded, this disc contains by no means all of them. For instance, the series called ‘The Music of …’, represented here by his Housman and Whitman cycles, also includes settings of Michael Drayton, Keats, Byron, Yeats and ‘most of the famous poets’. Perhaps we may anticipate further recordings, covering more of these songs, some of which have an obbligato instrument in addition to the piano.
Corp destroyed most of his teenage compositions, with one exception, which is heard here: a setting of Tennyson’s ‘Break, break, break’, written in 1966. ‘I could not throw this song away’, he says.
The range of songs on this disc is wide, ranging in style ‘from art song to the more overtly humorous’. This includes songs he has written for children’s voices, but one would not guess this, listening to the performances here, for they sit quite comfortably side by side with the ‘grown-up’ pieces.
Much of the credit for this goes to the two performers, the baritone Mark Stone and the pianist Simon Lepper, both absolutely impeccable from beginning to end. My only criticism - and it’s a very mild one - is that Stone is sometimes rather too gentlemanly, and I feel could roughen his voice or be a bit more uninhibited when the words and music call for it. Something of what might have been is heard at the end of Corp’s setting of Harry Graham’s wonderful poem ‘The Bath’, which would make a very suitable encore, particularly in a programme of ‘songs on a watery theme’, which was the context for which it was originally written, at the request of the mezzo-soprano Catherine Hopper.
Here too are pieces by writers less commonly set to music, Byron and Mervyn Peake, but those that are more familiar, such as Housman, are represented by less familiar verse – ‘It nods and curtseys and recovers’, ‘Now hollow fires burn out to black’ and ‘Stone, steel, dominions pass’, for example. ‘I also wanted the music to be a little abrasive because I felt that some past settings of Housman had veered, to their detriment, towards the genteel’, says the composer. ‘Housman’s irony and gritty pessimism’ (as Geoffrey Bush once described it) can be difficult to capture but Corp does, I think, succeed in doing so.
The only song I would not care to hear again, despite the advocacy of composer and performers, is Colin Coppen’s ‘Give to my eyes, Lord’: long lines and six seemingly endless verses of it. And yet, it is apparently popular enough for the Oxford University Press to publish it in versions for children’s choirs, adult choirs, and as a solo song – as on this disc. A purely personal view, but I feel Corp becomes a trifle sentimental, here and elsewhere, when faced with religious texts of a certain sort. The choral versions, with their greater scope for varied vocal colour and texture, are perhaps more palatable.
But the strength of this disc lies in the three song cycles, by Whitman and Housman and
Flower of Cities, an anthology of London poems by Dunbar, Byron, Wordsworth, Blake and Henry Carey, which opens the programme. This and
The Music of Housman include a Corp characteristic: a ‘reprise’ – a modified repeat of the opening, giving a sense of unity to the cycle.
The most substantial item, the Whitman cycle, is very fine, and although written in 1973 this is not only its first recording but in fact its first performance, which rather shocks me, for I am certain that the composer gave me a copy of this work sometime in the 1970s which for some reason I never sang and subsequently appear to have lost. I feel very foolish and very, very ashamed.
There are thirty-nine songs on this disc and it is a tribute to all involved that interest very seldom wanes. More please.
-- Garry Humphreys, MusicWeb Internation
Works on This Recording
Flower of Cities: No. 1. To the City of London
Flower of Cities: No. 2. The Distant Prospect
Flower of Cities: No. 3. Sonnet Composed Upon Westminster Bridge
Flower of Cities: No. 4. London
Flower of Cities: No. 5. Glide Gently
Flower of Cities: No. 6. London is a Fine Town
Flower of Cities: No. 7. To the City of London (reprise)
Kaleidoscope: No. 12. The Owl and the Pussycat
Cornucopia (excerpts): No. 3. The Irish Pig
Cornucopia (excerpts): No. 6. Weep You No More, Sad Fountains
Cornucopia (excerpts): No. 8. Sensitive, Seldom and Sad
Cornucopia (excerpts): No. 9. The Ship of Rio
The Music of Housman: No. 1. Into My Heart an Air that Kills
The Music of Housman: No. 2. Oh, When I Was in Love with You
The Music of Housman: No. 3. It Nods and Curtseys and Recovers
The Music of Housman: No. 4. You Smile Upon Your Friend To-Day
The Music of Housman: No. 5. Now Hollow Fries Burn Out to Black
The Music of Housman: No. 6. In the Morning, in the Morning
The Music of Housman: No. 7. The Sigh that Heaves the Grasses
The Music of Housman: No. 8. When Green Buds Hang in the Elm Like Dust
The Music of Housman: No. 9. I Promise Nothing - Friends Will Part
The Music of Housman: No. 10. Stone, Steel, Dominions Pass
The Music of Housman: No. 11. He, Standing Hushed, a Pace or Two Apart
The Music of Housman: No. 12. Into My Heart an Air that Kills (reprise)
Toward the Unknown Region
The Music of Whitman: No. 1. For Him I Sing
The Music of Whitman: No. 2. I Am He that Aches with Love
The Music of Whitman: No. 3. Sometimes with One I Love
The Music of Whitman: No. 4. Look Down Fair Moon
The Music of Whitman: No. 5. What am I After All
The Music of Whitman: No. 6. As if a Phantom Caress'd Me
The Music of Whitman: No. 7. The Last Invocation
The Music of Whitman: No. 8. A Clear Midnight
The Music of Whitman: No. 9. Joy, Shipmate, Joy!
The Music of Whitman: No. 10. Then Last of All
Be the first to review this title