Notes and Editorial Reviews
Really, so much fun shouldn’t come this cheap.
I came late to John McGlinn’s Broadway recordings, welcoming the reissue of
Annie Get Your Gun and the
Jerome Kern Treasury. Painstaking research and reconstruction, a roster of good singers – opera stars among them – and sassy, loose-limbed playing from the London Sinfonietta combine in recordings of real spirit and charm. Canny collectors will be pleased to discover that EMI’s big Broadway box – 13 CDs in all – can be had for under £20 online. In a market already awash with such sets, this must be one of the best bargains around.
In the meantime, EMI – past masters at the art of repackaging – have seen fit to reissue these discs
separately, albeit at super-low prices. The downside is that the paperwork is skimpy and artwork uninspired; transfers are sometimes on the bright side too, but that matters little when the music-making is as infectious as this.
Anything Goes certainly had a difficult gestation, but the end result is a show with more than its fair share of classic numbers. The overture has all the fizz and frolic one expects from McGlinn and his big bands – the LSO trombones are especially fine, rhythms as catchy as one could hope for. It never ceases to amaze me what chameleons our best orchestras are, switching easily between core classics and the exhibitionism and extravagance of American musicals. The shipboard shenanigans get under way with Kim Criswell’s delectable rendition of ‘I get a kick out of you’ – how embraceable that burbling tune is made to sound – and a rousing, streamer-filled ‘Bon voyage’ from the Ambrosian Singers.
It’s so easy to surrender to this music, Cris Groenendaal and Frederica von Stade’s ‘All through the night’ full of stars and velvet skies. One of the hallmarks of this McGlinn series is the occasional use of opera singers – Thomas Hampson in
Annie, for instance – a crossover that works pretty well; certainly, von Stade makes an attractive Hope Harcourt, the oh-so-distant object of Billy Crocker’s affections. But the ensemble pieces are even more delightful, the sailors’ shanty-inspired ‘There’ll always be a lady fair’ wonderfully warm and witty. It’s good to hear the late-lamented Bruce Hubbard among them – he made a real impact in McGlinn’s
Show Boat and Rattle’s
Porgy and Bess.
So, any nits to pick? No, not really. The cast is uniformly good, the playing is beyond reproach and the recording has sparkle and space. I’m not always keen on Criswell’s delivery though, her Mermanesque bawl and tendency to snarl under pressure a tad wearying after a while. In the meantime, there’s a conveyor-belt of great tunes, ‘You’re the top’ and ‘Anything goes’ dispatched with commendable zest. The trombones in the latter – so suggestive of Glenn Miller and the big bands of the next decade – are just superb, McGlinn upping the tempo in the most natural way.
The second act is no less enjoyable, from the knee-bending G&S pastiche of ‘Public enemy number one' – to von Stade’s dreamy take on ‘What a joy to be young’. Turn down the lights, kick back and just wallow in those languid rhythms, the mood judged to perfection. And for once Criswell’s bugle-like tones pay off in ‘Blow, Gabriel blow’. That’s followed by Broadway and Hollywood veteran Jack Gilford’s strangely vulnerable rendition of Moonface Martin’s ‘Be like the bluebird’. A real trouper, Gilford died of stomach cancer just two years later.
But I just can’t end on a blue note, for there’s still the mock-sultriness of von Stade’s ‘The gypsy in me’ and three excised items in the shape of ‘There’s no cure like travel’, ‘Kate the great’ and ‘Waltz down the aisle’. You know, with so many of these glorious McGlinn discs still to cross my desk I’m more tempted than ever to buy that big box. Really, so much fun shouldn’t come this cheap.
-- Dan Morgan, MusicWeb International
Works on This Recording
Anything Goes by Cole Porter
Dustin Stacks (Voice),
Judy Green (Voice),
Rebecca Caine (Voice),
Byran Landrine (Tenor),
Kim Criswell (Soprano),
Cris Groenendaal (Tenor),
Frederica Von Stade (Mezzo Soprano),
Jack Gilford (Voice),
Michael B. Wailing (Voice),
Bruce Hubbard (Baritone),
Del-Bourree Bach (Bass),
Simon Green (Voice),
Phil Ossafee (Voice)
London Symphony Orchestra,
Anything Goes, Act I: I get a kick out of you (Reno)
Anything Goes, Act I: Bon voyage (Boys, Girls)
Anything Goes, Act I: All through the night (Billy, Hope, Sailors)
Anything Goes, Act I: There'll always be a lady fair (Four Sailors)
Anything Goes, Act I: Where are the men? (1st & 2nd Girls, Girls' Chorus)
Anything Goes, Act I: You're the top (Billy, Reno)
Anything Goes, Act I: Encore: You're the top (Reno, Billy)
Anything Goes, Act I: Reprise: There'll always be a lady fair (Four Sailors)
Anything Goes, Act I: Anything Goes (Reno, Four Sailors)
Anything Goes, Act I: Finale Act I (Sailor No. 1, Captain, Billy, Hope, Reno, Moonface)
Anything Goes, Act II: Public Enemy Number One (Four Sailors, Passengers)
Anything Goes, Act II: What a joy to be young (Hope)
Anything Goes, Act II: Blow, Gabriel, blow (Reno, Company)
Anything Goes, Act II: Be like the bluebird (Moonface)
Anything Goes, Act II: Buddie, beware (Reno)
Anything Goes, Act II: The gypsy in me (Hope)
Anything Goes, Act II: Finale Ultimo (All) (Reprise: You're the top - Anything Goes) (Reprise: You're the top - Anything Goes): Anything Goes, Act II: Finale Ultimo (All) (Reprise: You're the top - Anything Goes)
Anything Goes, Appendix: There's no cure like travel (Boys, Girls)
Anything Goes, Appendix: Kate the Great (Reno, Angels)
Anything Goes, Appendix: Waltz down the aisle (Evelyn, Hope)
Be the first to review this title