Leonard Bernstein was always a very impressive Beethoven conductor. When this set was first released, it was received somewhat tepidly, largely on account of Bernstein’s “espressivo” style in the Fifth, and also the occasional roughness in the playing of the New York Philharmonic. The comparison, naturally, was to the extremely smooth and polished Berlin Philharmonic under Karajan, whose 1963 cycle was viewed as the acme of great orchestral playing–which, of its kind, it was. Then Bernstein re-recorded all of these works with the Vienna Philharmonic for DG, and that was that as far as these performances were concerned. Heard from today’s perspective, after decades of “authentic” performances of a timbral crudeness that are to Bernstein whatRead more Bernstein was to Karajan, perhaps it’s time for a reappraisal.
In the first place, Bernstein isn’t all bluster and excess. The first two symphonies have plenty of stylish playing and conducting supporting their energetic cast. Those crucial bass lines in the finale of the Fifth speak more powerfully here than they do in Vienna, and the special affinity that Bernstein has always felt for the Eroica and Seventh Symphonies are very much in evidence. Granted, the Ninth has to make due with an average cast of soloists (Martina Arroyo aside), and the Juilliard Chorus is good but not great, but then this is true of so many versions of this symphony; certainly Bernstein’s interpretation has plenty of fire and a genuinely hushed intensity in the Adagio. The Pastoral too has lots of rustic character, with the last three movements particularly well paced.
The overtures are marvelous: Leonore No. 3 and The Consecration of the House are especially outstanding. As for the Violin Concerto, Isaac Stern’s recordings have much the same reputation as Bernstein’s first Beethoven cycle: good, but somehow in the second tier. Is this deserved? I’m not so sure. This is a beautiful performance, serene but not lacking energy in the first movement, expressively flowing in Larghetto, and full of physical energy in the finale. Soloist and accompanist work very well together; nothing sounds routine or taken for granted.
Sonically these recordings have held up well; they never were great, but they capture the performances with a certain unvarnished directness that seems to suit the interpretations, and they have been well remastered. At budget price, you can try this set and decide for yourself if it deserves a higher reputation than that granted by received opinion over the years.
Egmont, Op. 84: Overtureby Ludwig van Beethoven Conductor:
New York Philharmonic
Period: Classical Written: 1810; Vienna, Austria
Die Weihe des Hauses, Op. 124by Ludwig van Beethoven Conductor:
New York Philharmonic
Period: Classical Written: 1822; Vienna, Austria
Concerto for Violin in D major, Op. 61by Ludwig van Beethoven Performer:
Isaac Stern (Violin)
New York Philharmonic
Period: Classical Written: 1806; Vienna, Austria
Average Customer Review: ( 3 Customer Reviews )
BernsteinJune 2, 2015By Eugene P. (San Francisco, CA)See All My Reviews"Bernstein's Beethoven has been criticized as being romantic. If so its not a problem here, but rather a welcome antidote to metronomic period Beethoven. These are generally exciting and well played with excellent sound. Better sound than the original LPs. Only the first movement of the 9th came off poorly, too slow and limp; the slow movement is beautiful though."Report Abuse
Essential Basic Repertoire Done With SpiritJune 2, 2015By Thomas R. (Centennial, CO)See All My Reviews"I purchased this recording as a gift for my grandson, who has taken an interest in classical music from riding in my car and listening to the radio, which is always tuned to my local classical music station. He was curious as he'd not encountered that elsewhere and I wanted to capitalize on his interest to further foster his appreciation of the art. Bernstein's and the NY Phil's version of Beethoven Symphonies has been in my possession for almost 50 years, in the original Columbia vinyl issue. That recording has provided me countless hours of listening pleasure and my hope that my grandson will experience the same. Thanks to Arkiv for making this release available and supplementing it with excellent service."Report Abuse
The Bernstein NineNovember 21, 2014By Gregory W. (Hinckley, OH)See All My Reviews"Many years ago I had the original Columbia Masterworks issue of the Beethoven 4th and 8th symphonies performed by Lenny and the NY Philharmonic, and it was the only LP of this set that I owned. I did not find them particularly interesting (bear in mind that this was way before digitalization, Dolby noise reduction and all the other sound enhancements we take for granted today). So out of pure curiosity I bought the set re-issued on CD with Sony's now famous 24 bit high resolution audio. And the result? I can't quite go into all the details but I find these performances now quite amazing. Even if you're not a Bernstein fan you should have these. These renditions allow you to learn more about Bernstein the conductor than a cold literary review. The Philharmonic plays, oh do they play, in some movements, and the remainder what you would expect of a seasoned disciplined orchestra. For the money what've you got to lose? Recommended."Report Abuse
YOU MUST BE A SUBSCRIBER TO LISTEN TO ARKIVMUSIC STREAMING.
TRY IT NOW FOR FREE!
Sign up now for two weeks of free access to the world's best classical music collection. Keep listening for only $19.95/month - thousands of classical albums for the price of one! Learn more about ArkivMusic Streaming