WGBH Radio WGBH Radio theclassicalstation.org

Weill: Lost In The Stars / Rudel, Concert Chorale Of New York

Release Date: 10/13/2009 
Label:  Nimbus   Catalog #: 2543   Spars Code: DDD 
Composer:  Kurt Weill
Performer:  Reginald PindellGregory HopkinsArthur WoodleyCynthia Clarey,   ... 
Conductor:  Julius Rudel
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Orchestra of St. Luke'sConcert Chorale of New York
Number of Discs: 1 
Recorded in: Stereo 
In Stock: Usually ships in 24 hours.  

Notes and Editorial Reviews

Weill’s last completed work given a fine, dramatic reading.

Lost in the Stars is Weill’s last completed work. It was based on the novel, Cry the Beloved Country by the South African writer, Alan Paton (1903-1988) and represents a very speedy adaptation, since Paton’s book was only published in 1948. Yet by the following year Weill and his librettist, Maxwell Anderson (1888-1959), had written the musical, which opened on Broadway in October 1949, where the original production ran for 273 performances.
In brief, the story concerns Stephen Kumalo, an African pastor, serving in a South African country parish, whose son, Absalom, has gone off to find work and a better life in
Read more Johannesburg. There he meets Irina, who conceives their child, but he also falls in with some less suitable male company and with these men he takes part in a burglary, during the course of which a white man – ironically, a campaigner for racial equality in Paton’s novel - is killed. When Stephen, unaware of these events, arrives in Johannesburg to search for his son he eventually finds the pregnant Irina and then locates his son, who is in jail, awaiting trial.
Inevitably Absalom is found guilty and sentenced to death. Not only are father and son reconciled but Stephen realises Irina’s worth. He marries the couple in jail so that their child will have Absalom’s name, and then takes Irina back to the family home and his parish where she is taken into the family’s care before the death sentence on Absalom is carried out.
This is emphatically not a conventional subject for a Broadway musical – like the earlier groundbreaking Showboat, which addressed the issue of miscegenation, it tackles a tough subject but it’s much more gritty than Jerome Kern’s great show. As David Kilroy observes in his excellent note, Lost in the Stars created in 1949 “a musico-dramatic parable of a new social order for an American public floundering with its own racial prejudices in the immediate postwar era.” In fact, in many ways it takes us back to the world of Weill’s collaborations with Bertolt Brecht. For example, there are some similarities in the musical styles. The scoring is for a small ensemble of some sixteen players and quite often the instrumental writing is pungent in a way that recalls those Brecht shows.
Lost in the Stars was Weill’s last completed work and it’s a fine creation, its quality emphasised by this excellent performance. We only get the musical numbers together with some of the spoken dialogue but the story line is not compromised.
The musical invention is strong; there are several memorable numbers in the show. The best of them fall to the character of Stephen and, in a strong cast, Arthur Woodley is one of the best performers of all. He has a fine, firm voice. His tone is consistently strong and round and his diction is excellent – though the libretto is printed it’s almost superfluous since all the cast enunciate very clearly. Woodley brings dignity and intensity to the role and among the highlights of the entire performance are his renditions of ‘Little Gray House’ and the title song. He also gives an excellent account of the emotionally charged soliloquy, ‘O Tixo, Tixo, Help Me!’ in Act II.
The other principal character is Irina, Absalom’s girlfriend. Cynthia Clarey gives a strong account of Irina’s music, singing ‘Stay Well’ expressively and delivering the touching ‘Trouble Man’ with real feeling. My one reservation is that her voice is a big, mature instrument and it might be thought rather too heavy to suggest a young, frightened and vulnerable girl.
Also impressive is Gregory Hopkins as the Leader of the chorus. He has a ringing, pliant tenor voice, which serves the opening number ‘The Hills of Ixopo’ very well. Even better is the ardent song, ‘Cry the Beloved Country’. Incidentally, great trouble has evidently been taken to ensure authentic pronunciation by all the cast; an adviser from the South African embassy, Tuli Demikude, was retained specially for this purpose
The chorus and orchestra are very fine indeed, bringing out all the tension and bite in Weill’s score but providing the right emotional charge. Julius Rudel directs proceedings with evident commitment to the score. The rhythms are kept tight and the memorable tunes flow most convincingly.
The recorded sound is perhaps a little close but not in any troubling way. Indeed, there’s rather a feel of the performance being mounted in a small theatre. Perhaps, though, that feeling is more down to the dramatic flair of this performance. The work clearly matters a great deal to Rudel, who says in a brief introductory comment that he regards it as “a composition of great depth, deceptively couched in simple settings.” That belief in the score shines through in his fine, dramatic reading.
Originally made for the MusicMasters catalogue, it’s excellent news that the recording has now been reissued by Nimbus. All admirers of Kurt Weill will want to add it to their collections but it should be heard by anyone interested in the unique art-form that is the American Musical.
-- John Quinn, MusicWeb International
Read less

Works on This Recording

Lost in the Stars by Kurt Weill
Performer:  Reginald Pindell (Baritone), Gregory Hopkins (Tenor), Arthur Woodley (Baritone),
Cynthia Clarey (Soprano), Carol Woods (Voice), Jamal Howard (Boy Soprano)
Conductor:  Julius Rudel
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Orchestra of St. Luke's,  Concert Chorale of New York

Customer Reviews

Average Customer Review:  1 Customer Review )
 Worthy Effort, With One Weakness July 22, 2013 By Henry S. (Springfield, VA) See All My Reviews "In this review, I'll be disagreeing to some extent with Arkivmusic's professional critic, and I want to stress that this reflects only my personal opinion. Based on the novel 'Cry The Beloved Country', Lost in the Stars tells a tragic tale of lost faith and despair in the era of South African apartheid. Lasting only about 70 minutes, the predominantly African-American cast sings movingly and often poignantly in a gritty, ultra-realistic plot that pleads with the listener to consider and reflect on the grotesque reality of racially-based human disenfranchisement and loss of identity and dignity. The recording is actually a collection of the songs from the stage production, and in that respect it resembles more the recording of a Broadway play than a standard opera. I found the singing to be very well done and very effective in creating an overall sense of tragic pathos. What I consider to be the problem with this recording is its sparse orchestration. I do not know if Kurt Weill himself called for such minimal orchestral accompaniment, or if conductor Julius Rudel chose the approach used here. Whatever the cause, the Orchestra of St. Luke's was pared down to only 16 members (the musicians were specifically listed in the booklet notes), which is far too few in my view. I look to an opera orchestra to help create the emotional ambience in which the singers can operate... and I didn't quite get it here. It can be argued that such reduced forces fit the tragic and even gruesome plot perfectly, but I still think that a larger orchestra would have worked better. In the end, despite my feeling on the orchestral support provided, I do think this recording has merit and deserves to be heard." Report Abuse
Review This Title