Notes and Editorial Reviews
Laurence Cummings, cond; Catherine Manley (
); Alexandra Gibson (
); Allan Clayton (
); Richard Rowntree (
); George Humphreys (
); London Handel Singers; London Handel O (period instruments)
SOMM 240 (2 CDs: 118:36
Text and Translation) Live: London 3/13/2008
The performance preserved on this recording is built around half an aria. When Handel revived
for the first time in 1752, he rewrote the B section of Achsah’s act I aria “Hark! ’tis the linnet and the thrush.” All other recordings have used the revised version as printed in Chrysander’s score (with inaccuracies, according to this recording’s notes). In all other respects, the score is the same as that used in other recordings.
Laurence Cummings leads a very good performance. He sets reasonable tempos and is alive to what dramatic life Handel was able to infuse into the rather static libretto. Among the best recordings of
, Cummings is the only conductor who correctly observes the details of historical performance practice. Both Robert King (Hyperion) and Peter Neumann (MDG) frequently (and incorrectly) use organ (usually accompanied by theorbo or lute) in place of the harpsichord in recitatives and arias. Cummings does not even use a theorbo or lute, and we have no evidence that Handel used such an instrument in his performances after 1739.
Cummings uses a rather small orchestra by Handelian standards. Strings are 4/4/2/2/1, and the orchestra can occasionally sound a little thin, for example in the march near the beginning of act II. But for the most part the orchestra sounds full enough; King (7/6/3/3/2) and Neumann (6/5/3/2/2) with their larger groups never sound underpowered. Because this is a live performance, there is the very occasional small lack of precision in ensemble, but this is not really a problem. The occasional stage noise is the only other hint that this is a live production; the audience is extremely quiet, except for the applause at the end of each act.
The London Handel Singers are also the smallest of the choral groups in the major recordings, with a mixed ensemble of 18 singers. King’s all-male chorus numbers 30, while Neumann uses a mixed chorus of 28. All three groups are excellent.
Cummings has assembled an outstanding set of soloists. All cope well with the florid music they are given to sing. Allan Clayton, though not quite as elegant as John Mark Ainsley for King, is a forceful Joshua; James Gilchrist for Neumann is also outstanding. Catherine Manley as Achsah is sweet and supple of voice, as are her competitors, Emma Kirkby for King and Myung-Hee Hyun for Neumann. Handel wrote the role of Othniel for a female contralto, and Cummings is the only one of the three conductors to cast a female in the role. Alexandra Gibson begins a bit tentatively, but she soon settles down to provide a good performance. I prefer her singing to that of James Bowman for King. Alex Potter for Neumann is also good, but I confess to a preference for natural voices. George Humphreys is the best of the three basses; though all are good, Michael George for King is somewhat wooly-voiced, while Konstantin Wolff for Neumann is not quite as smooth in coloratura as the other two. The small tenor role of the Angel is given to a boy treble in King’s recording.
Do you need to rush out and buy this recording? If you already have King or Neumann, the answer is probably not (unless, like me, you are a Handel completist who simply must have every note Handel wrote). But if you are looking for your first recording of
, or you can afford multiple recordings, this
is the recording to buy. By a small margin, it has become my preferred recording.
FANFARE: Ron Salemi
Works on This Recording
Joshua, HWV 64 by George Frideric Handel
Alexandra Gibson (Alto),
George Humphreys (Baritone),
Richard Rowntree (Tenor),
Allan Clayton (Tenor)
London Handel Orchestra,
London Handel Singers
Written: 1748; London, England
Be the first to review this title