Davis lays more emphasis upon musical than dramatic values, with splendid playing and thrilling contributions by the nearly 150-voice chorus. Unlike light (or “lite”) Messiahs of the past quarter century, Davis’ is rich, warm, and weighty without being turgid or lugubrious (tempos middle-of-the-road to fast). Winds augment, sometimes dominating or replacing strings; snare drums work only in the already somewhat militaristic “Thou shalt break them,” but tambourines lend an appropriately festive air to “Great was the company.” As befits the conception, the soloists all have larger voices than typical. Excellent sound.
– The Absolute Sound
I have no hesitation in recommending this as anRead more enjoyable second or third Messiah for anyone’s collection. It is, for sure, too idiosyncratic—and indeed truncated—to be a first choice or an appropriate recording through which to learn the work. But if your palate needs refreshing after hearing too many Messiahs that sound pretty much identical, then go for it. You would be a hard-hearted listener indeed if you didn’t feel invigorated by what Davis has to offer.
– MusicWeb International
The radical and experimental approach to the orchestration here is something of a throwback to the needlessly interventionist past, but that does not make the reading any less enjoyable—although it is not one for purists. Recorded live on SACD, this unique version makes use of all the colours available from the modern symphony orchestra to underline the mood and meaning of the individual movements. Without detracting from the innate power of the original, the conductor’s score calls for moments of drama, pathos, and even, sometimes, whimsicality. It is supported by substantial brass and woodwind forces, and several percussion instruments (including marimba!).
Messiah, HWV 56by George Frideric Handel Performer:
John Relyea (Bass),
Erin Wall (Soprano),
Elizabeth Deshong (Mezzo Soprano),
Andrew Staples (Tenor)
Sir Andrew Davis
Toronto Symphony Orchestra,
Toronto Mendelssohn Choir
Period: Baroque Written: 1741; London, England
Average Customer Review: ( 5 Customer Reviews )
A Disappointment January 18, 2018By Lawrence E. (glenview, IL)See All My Reviews"This is a CD I will never listen to again. A total disappointment. On Christmas day I pop it in expecting one kind of afternoon, and I'm getting quite another. I'm hearing flutes, clarinets to start. Uh oh. I look at the different info... and it's the "Sir Andrew Davis edition". I hear trombones, snare drums, cymbals, and other crop ups. Singing is decent... but there is no baroque (ok, hardly any) sparkle. In my view, adding these instruments doesn't make it grander. It makes it neutralized... just the opposite of the intention. That's just me. A for effort. Personal enjoyment factor? C- addendum: the choir is a little further back in the mix to make sure we hear the orchestration. Including glockenspiel! And GONG!!!! (The following day I listened to Robert Shaw Chorale, and what a dream!)"Report Abuse
Bravo Handel and DavisNovember 5, 2017By G. Brown (River Edge, NJ)See All My Reviews"After hearing the Beecham recording of Sir Goossen's blasphemous orchestration of Handel's masterpiece, I was sceptical of this release. However, Sir Andrew's orchestration is not only marvelously conceived, it draws out inner detail of Handel's masterpiece that, in a good way, maximizes the harmony, drama and word painting of the work without bombastic histrionics. It is an orchestration that is faithful to the great Handel. I believe Handel himself would be pleased. Highly recommended."Report Abuse
My "Big" Wonderful MessiahJune 4, 2017By Joseph F. (Stamford, CT)See All My Reviews"Wow! Just what I was looking for in a recording of Handel's "Messiah"-- a big orchestra and chorus version that still retains the quick pace and excitement of the period instrument movement. Some of the old recordings, pre- revival of gut strings and two-on-a-part singing of the Handel warhorse, sound wonderful in their own ways, but they can sound ponderous compared to current "thinking" on Handel. This recording has the massed forces playing with new "additions" by Sir Andrew Davis at a very decent speed and with great dynamic variation and excitement. If no one else is at home, crank this up and have a great evening. This is my "go to" politically incorrect version of "Messiah" it is wonderful. Oh, and don't get me wrong, it's not bombastic or overdone in any way. It is aesthetically very pleasing, and the aria, "I know my Redeemer Liveth" may be the best I have ever heard."Report Abuse