WGBH Radio WGBH Radio theclassicalstation.org

Vaughan Williams, Sibelius: Symphony No 4 / Sargent, Bbc So

Release Date: 05/13/2008 
Label:  Bbc Legends   Catalog #: 4237   Spars Code: n/a 
Composer:  Ralph Vaughan WilliamsJean Sibelius
Conductor:  Sir Malcolm Sargent
Orchestra/Ensemble:  BBC Symphony Orchestra
Number of Discs: 1 
Recorded in: Stereo 
Length: 1 Hours 8 Mins. 

In Stock: Usually ships in 24 hours.  

Notes and Editorial Reviews

All the dangerous intensity of a live event.

Here are two individualistic, angry or brooding fourth symphonies. They are conducted by Malcolm Sargent whose reputation glowed brightly through his association with the Promenade concerts and the great choral festivals of the 1940s and 1950. For a long while he was venerated and rather like Kathleen Ferrier was counted among the saintly Elect - beyond criticism. However his following and his popularity faded in the wake of his death. Extra-musical factors also played their part in disenchantment including his ruthlessly dry-eyed approach to orchestral musicians. In this he was not alone.

In the present disc we get a chance to reassess Sargent in two Proms
Read more performances preserved in broadcast stereo. It’s very much to his credit. We hear him in symphonies each of which represented a crashing gear-change for their composers. Sibelius 4 can still seem a difficult pill to swallow. Its emotional distancing, cold and even shivering dissonance are such a contrast with the first two symphonies and even with the benevolent classical pantheism of the Third. As for the Vaughan Williams one has only to compare it with its neighbours: the lamenting beauty of The Pastoral with its trumpets echoing across devastated battlefields and the seraphic Bunyanesque paragraphs of the Fifth Symphony.

The RVW Fourth is given as furious a first movement as you are likely to have heard - white hot goaded and driven in the manner of the composer's famous 1930s recording with the same orchestra. There is repose but where the score indicates extremes of speed Sargent applies them with a will. I confess that it is exhilarating if not quite as white hot as the Mitropoulos version. As for Sargent’s Sibelius he recorded the Second and Fifth Symphonies, Pohjola's Daughter and other popular shorter pieces variously with the BBCSO and the Vienna PO for EMI Classics. They are or were available on an EMI Seraphim double. His Fourth is, by contrast with the RVW4, a slowly savoured performance which in the first movement brings out the soulful side of the music. In fact this memorably different approach pays dividends when the grander climaxes come. It is interesting to hear Sargent's way with this music taken down within months of Karajan's classic commercial recording for DG. Let's not forget that Sibelius was during the 1960s still something of an outré taste and there must still have been doubts whether fashion was turning in his favour. There's a lot of audience noise, bronchial and fidgeting, but it's an integral part of the atmosphere which you can cut with a knife in this recording. This is more than enough compensation for the occasional slip such as the muffed entry by the horn at 2.10 in the finale of Sibelius 4 and some sour notes from the brass later in the movement.

Perhaps we can now hope for archive recordings of Sargent’s versions of Martin?'s Epic of Gilgamesh, Alwyn's Lyra Angelica and RVW’s Ninth Symphony to be issued. I fervently hope so. An aside but having mentioned Martin? I wonder whether anyone has recoverable recordings of Tausky's BBC 1950s studio cycle of Martin? symphonies.

The technical quality for these two recordings is stunning - a tribute to the BBC engineers of those days. It's the Proms so you must however get used to coughs and shuffling. In overwhelming compensation you experience all the dangerous intensity of a live event.

Rob Barnett, MusicWeb International
Read less

Works on This Recording

Symphony no 4 in F minor by Ralph Vaughan Williams
Conductor:  Sir Malcolm Sargent
Orchestra/Ensemble:  BBC Symphony Orchestra
Period: 20th Century 
Written: 1931-1934; England 
Date of Recording: 8/16/1963 
Venue:  Live  Live Royal Albert Hall, London 
Length: 31 Minutes 12 Secs. 
Symphony no 4 in A minor, Op. 63 by Jean Sibelius
Conductor:  Sir Malcolm Sargent
Orchestra/Ensemble:  BBC Symphony Orchestra
Period: 20th Century 
Written: 1911; Finland 
Date of Recording: 9/2/1965 
Venue:  Live  Live Royal Albert Hall, London 
Length: 35 Minutes 5 Secs. 

Customer Reviews

Be the first to review this title
Review This Title