WGBH Radio WGBH Radio theclassicalstation.org

Brahms: Symphonies 1 & 2 / Gergiev

Brahms / London Symphony Orch / Gergiev
Release Date: 10/08/2013 
Label:  Lso Live   Catalog #: 733   Spars Code: n/a 
Composer:  Johannes Brahms
Conductor:  Valery Gergiev
Orchestra/Ensemble:  London Symphony Orchestra
Number of Discs: 2 
Recorded in: Mixed 
Length: 2 Hours 5 Mins. 

Low Stock: Currently 3 or fewer in stock. Usually ships in 24 hours, unless stock becomes depleted.  
On sale! $18.98
SuperAudio CD:  $16.99
Low Stock

Notes and Editorial Reviews

BRAHMS Symphonies: Nos 1 and 2. Tragic Overture. Variations on a Theme of Haydn Valery Gergiev, cond; London SO LSO LIVE 0733 (2 SACDs: 125:18)

Valery Gergiev is not a conductor whose name immediately comes to mind in connection with Brahms, though I do have him leading excellent performances of the Brahms and Korngold violin concertos with Nikolaj Znaider and the Vienna Philharmonic. Here, however, Gergiev gives us a very generous portion of Brahms’s Read more orchestral works in a two-disc package that doesn’t stint on content. In recent reviews, I’ve spoken out against the practice of releasing recordings of the Brahms symphonies one per disc and with no filler. Such marketing is especially indefensible when it comes to Brahms, since he composed so few purely orchestral works, and those that he did compose, like the Academic Festival and Tragic overtures and the “Haydn” Variations, can each easily fit on a disc with any one of the four symphonies. Gergiev and LSO Live are therefore to be commended for doing exactly that.

All of these performances were recorded in concert at London’s Barbican between September and December 2012, and I have to say that I’m rather more impressed by Gergiev’s handling of these works than I expected to be, though I had no prior reason for skepticism. The metronomic juxtaposition between the First Symphony’s opening Un poco sostenuto and ensuing Allegro is textbook perfection—an exact parsing of the beat, in which six eighth-notes per bar of one beat each become two groups of three eighth-notes each felt as two beats per bar. You could set the atomic clock by it, and it’s accomplished with absolutely no sense of a gearshift. The oboe solo in the opening introduction is also shaped and phrased with rare beauty, and the exposition repeat is observed. Gergiev sets tempos for all four movements that feel just right—neither too fast nor two slow—and the London Symphony Orchestra’s players make positively radiant sounds.

Unlike some other Brahms Firsts I’ve reviewed in recent issues—Weingartner’s comes to mind—Gergiev’s burns at a somewhat lower temperature; it smolders rather than blazes, which is to say, it focuses less on the dramatic upheavals and volcanic outbursts of the score than it does on its lyrical aspects and underlying sense of mystery. Take, for example, the violent clash of opposing rhythms that reaches its final life-or-death battle just before the denouement of the first movement. Others—the aforementioned Weingartner and Bruno Walter, for example—whip this passage into a frenetic frenzy. Gergiev’s reading of it is more moderate and measured.

To tell the truth, some may find Gergiev just a bit too measured for their taste, not so much in terms of tempo, but in terms of strict adherence to the beat. One doesn’t experience quite the feeling of forward drive and adrenaline rush that come with those conductors whose control is a bit more elastic and who are willing to submit to the music’s natural impulses. It was the utter naturalness of flow, among other things, that led me to praise Daniel Raiskin’s recent Brahms cycle with the Rhenish State Philharmonic Orchestra (see 35: 5).

Still, one has to admire and appreciate Gergiev’s technical accomplishment, for this is an exceptionally intelligent and magnificently executed Brahms First. The Tragic Overture, always a compatible companion to the First Symphony, fills out disc one. But the performance of the Overture wasn’t pieced together from the same concerts as the Symphony. The Symphony is a composite of widely spaced performances given on September 22nd and October 11th. The Overture is also a composite of widely spaced performances, but given on September 23rd and October 13th. While the Symphony sounds all of a piece, the Overture doesn’t. Not that there are any obvious splices or anything of that nature to be heard, but there seems to be a lack of continuity or consistency of vision to the reading. The tempo isn’t slow, yet it feels somehow sluggish and heavy, as if the orchestra is slow to respond to Gergiev’s direction. At 7:43, just before the onset of the fugal episode midway through the piece, Gergiev indulges in a highly exaggerated and elongated ritard, and then launches the fugue at a painfully slow tempo, which loses the dramatic thrust. This, I’d have to say, is the one cupcake in the batch that seems to have fallen a bit flat in the baking.

Any shortcomings in the Tragic Overture are more than made up for in Gergiev’s reading of Brahms’s Second Symphony. This, quite simply, is one of the comeliest and most beguiling performances of the score I’ve heard. It flows with a warm, relaxed feeling, but doesn’t downplay the moments of heightened tension. Also to be noted is Gergiev’s absolutely ravishing handling of Brahms’s not altogether elegant first ending and lead-back to the repeat of the exposition in the first movement. I’ve always felt there was something a bit awkward and contrived sounding about this passage, as if it doesn’t quite fit, but Gergiev arrives back at the beginning with the silky smoothness of a hand slipping into a perfectly fitting glove. I don’t think I’ve ever heard this seam joined so skillfully.

When it comes to Brahms’s Second, it’s the opening of the second movement by which I ultimately judge any performance. In those swelling and subsiding cello phrases is concentrated all of Brahms’s love-longing and hope, which hasn’t yet turned to the heartache of loss and loneliness. Gergiev portrays a still relatively young Brahms filled with feelings of an idyllic future. A cloud passes overheard every now and then, and an ominous warning in the form of a chromatically dire harmonic progression in the closing measures, foretell of a different fate that lies ahead, but Gergiev’s interpretation of the movement, and the Londoners’ playing of it, is breathtakingly gorgeous.

For me, the two variations that put the stamp of approval or rejection on a performance of the “Haydn” Variations are Nos. 5 and 8, the Andante con moto and the Presto non troppo . In the first instance, Brahms demonstrates his mastery of invertible counterpoint with a gorgeous minor-key variation that exchanges parts between the voices in the first and second halves. Gergiev draws from his London players a sinuous sound in which, enhanced by the LSO Live’s superb SACD recording, the lines seem to wrap around each other in an entwining, sensual embrace.

Variation No. 8 always puts me in mind of a chill wind whistling like a ghostly organ through the hallways of a haunted house. I’ve heard it played faster than Gergiev takes it—he’s mindful of Brahms’s non troppo qualifier—but I don’t think I’ve heard it sound any creepier than in Gergiev’s sotto voce approach.

In three out of these four performances, Valery Gergiev strides on stage, throws down the gauntlet, and accomplishes a coup, declaring himself a major new Brahms interpreter to be contended with. That’s quite an achievement, considering that up until now Brahms has not been a staple in Gergiev’s repertoire. I anxiously await the companion set containing the Third and Fourth symphonies. Besides the Academic Festival Overture, it will be interesting to see what Gergiev chooses as additional filler. I don’t think either of the serenades will fit, so my guess is, he’ll give us the composer-orchestrated Hungarian Dances . Meanwhile, this is very strongly recommended.

FANFARE: Jerry Dubins Read less

Works on This Recording

Symphony no 1 in C minor, Op. 68 by Johannes Brahms
Conductor:  Valery Gergiev
Orchestra/Ensemble:  London Symphony Orchestra
Period: Romantic 
Written: 1855-1876; Austria 
Venue:  Barbican, London 
Length: 48 Minutes 19 Secs. 
Tragic Overture, Op. 81 by Johannes Brahms
Conductor:  Valery Gergiev
Orchestra/Ensemble:  London Symphony Orchestra
Period: Romantic 
Written: 1880; Austria 
Venue:  Barbican, London 
Length: 14 Minutes 33 Secs. 
Symphony no 2 in D major, Op. 73 by Johannes Brahms
Conductor:  Valery Gergiev
Orchestra/Ensemble:  London Symphony Orchestra
Period: Romantic 
Written: 1877; Austria 
Venue:  Barbican, London 
Length: 44 Minutes 35 Secs. 
Variations in B flat major on a theme by Haydn, Op. 56a "St. Anthony" by Johannes Brahms
Conductor:  Valery Gergiev
Orchestra/Ensemble:  London Symphony Orchestra
Period: Romantic 
Written: 1873; Austria 
Venue:  Barbican, London 
Length: 15 Minutes 0 Secs. 

Customer Reviews

Average Customer Review:  2 Customer Reviews )
 I'd like to be equally enthusiastic as the initia April 15, 2014 By William C S. (Thousand Oaks, CA) See All My Reviews "and while I do not normally agree with Gramophone critics on many reviews, I found these performances dull, lackluster, uninflected, and only adequately played compared to much else that Gergiev has done with the LSO in his now long-termed relationship. Sorry, but there is zero enthusiasm here when we have at our disposal several fine complete cycles containing brilliant performances of #1 and #2(Bychkov (Avie), 1964 Karajan, Levine/CSO (Sony-BMG) and Levine/WPO (DG), Jochum 1979 (EMI), and individual performances by the same plus Ozawa/BSO (on Japanese DG), Kleiber/WPO (Philips CD and DVD), Kertesz in some rather elderly, raw-sounding but enthusiastic performances, and on the historical side Monteux (Philips) and van Beinum (also Philips) just to name a few. Neither of these performances demonstrate great sound, great orchestral articulation or excitement; they're in fact rather perfunctory. The Gramophone sums it up well. There is absolutely nothing to contend with here. Hopefully #3 and #4 will scintillate. I would very much like to have been more positive with the recent Prokofiev Cycle, outstanding recordings of Szymanowski, Ravel, Mahler, among others. This is not great Gergiev." Report Abuse
 Waiting for the 3rd and 4th November 8, 2013 By Joseph Lieber, MD (Great Neck, NY) See All My Reviews "Despite the dry recorded sound, Gergiev offers a beautifully paced and played Brahms program. The symphonies and the overtures, especially the Tragic have the right tempi and intensity. The LSO plays these works with their usual expertise.I'm not certain that these forces break any new ground but they certainly put on a solid and forceful performance. Looking forward to the next installment!" Report Abuse
Review This Title