Notes and Editorial Reviews
Bernstein's one-act opera from 1952, Trouble in Tahiti, remains an entertaining and affecting work. Its exploration of the emptiness of a marriage in trouble and its sometimes harsh view of suburban life may now seem familiar, but it was unusual and certainly forward-looking in the early 50s. Bernstein's libretto is intelligent and often quite inventive. We watch a day in the lives of Sam and Dinah, beginning at the breakfast table, moving through the office, the psychotherapist's couch, the gym, a hat shop, and back home again. Irony lurks everywhere, provided particularly by the trio of "radio singers," who function as a Greek chorus, separating scenes, commenting on the action, or performing backup duties. While the music is a
pastiche of popular and classical genres, suggesting Satie, vaudeville, the Modernaires, Broadway, Copland, and others, there are also features that have clearly influenced later composers and librettists. The often dark lyricism, the angular accompaniment figures, and the smart banter in some of the lyrics look forward to Sondheim. There are, in addition, some memorable melodies, and more than a few amusing moments, some provided by the Trio, but most found in Dinah's brilliant "What a movie."
This is an admirable performance by the Manhattan School of Music Opera Theater, which, while not always ideal, presents the score in a faithful and musical manner. Elizabeth Shammash as Dinah seems a bit subdued at first but improves consistently as the opera progresses—this is, of course, understandable in a live performance. Samuel Hepler is a good, solid Sam, producing a nice sound but lacking depth and, perhaps more important, variety in characterization. In their scenes together, Sam and Dinah often seem to be speaking to the audience rather than each other. The Trio is good, although they find it hard to overcome their operatic training—the pseudoscat in the opening chorus, for example, sounds rigid and studied. But Glen Cortese keeps things moving nicely, especially in Dinah's two big solos, at the therapist's and in the hat shop.
Two earlier recordings provide stiff competition for this new one. Bernstein's own from 1973 features Nancy Williams and Julian Patrick, who make a ferocious duo at the breakfast table, heightening the contrast with the blithe opening number. The Trio, led by Antonia Butler, who has an appropriately stylish, Jo Staffordish vibrato, is excellent, and Bernstein leads the performance with characteristic energy and style. A recording of the opera from the early 1950s led by Arthur Winograd has also reappeared on CD. Despite its odd recorded sound and some inaccuracies, it is the only one of these three performances in which the Trio really swings. While Sony's rerelease of Bernstein's performance remains the recommended one—especially since it is the least expensive and also includes the 1946 ballet Facsimile—all three of these recordings more than adequately display this inventive and often moving score.
-- Richard Burke, FANFARE [09/1999]
Works on This Recording
Trouble in Tahiti by Leonard Bernstein
Samuel Hepler (Baritone),
Micah Olson (Tenor),
Danielle Martin (Soprano),
Elizabeth Shammash (Mezzo Soprano),
Bryan Montemarano (Baritone)
Glen Barton Cortese
Manhattan School of Music Orchestra
Period: 20th Century
Written: 1952; USA
Be the first to review this title