WGBH Radio WGBH Radio theclassicalstation.org

18th Century Keyboard Concertos / Paul Nicholson


Release Date: 07/14/2009 
Label:  Helios   Catalog #: 55341   Spars Code: DDD 
Composer:  James HookPhilip HayesJames NaresThomas Chilcot,   ... 
Performer:  Paul Nicholson
Conductor:  Paul Nicholson
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Parley of Instruments
Number of Discs: 1 
Recorded in: Stereo 
Length: 1 Hours 16 Mins. 

In Stock: Usually ships in 24 hours.  

Notes and Editorial Reviews

Johann Sebastian Bach is generally considered the first composer in history to have written keyboard concertos. But Peter Holman, in his programme notes, suggests Handel had written at least a single movement for keyboard and instruments before Bach wrote his concertos. This disc opens with a Chaconne in G, which has survived as a piece for keyboard solo and probably dates from Handel's years in Hamburg. Recently I reviewed a recording of some of Handel's keyboard music by Siegbert Rampe. He also suggested this piece could originally have been conceived for harpsichord and orchestra, since "in the only source, a continental copy, the tutti and solo are differentiated, which admittedly could also mean that a large harpsichord was used Read more as a substitute for an orchestra". He played the Chaconne as it is preserved; here the string parts are reconstructed by Paul Nicholson. Having heard the result I am not quite convinced this is really the form which Handel had in mind. The strings only play the ritornello, and the soli for the keyboard in between them are so long that I wonder what is the point of adding strings. Maybe the alternative suggested by Siegbert Rampe is more plausible.

This is not the only concerto on this disc which has been reconstructed. Thomas Roseingrave's Concerto for organ and orchestra in D has survived as a piece for solo keyboard, and that is how Paul Nicholson has recorded it before. But he and Peter Holman had the impression it was a reduction of a keyboard concerto, which seemed to be confirmed when in a newspaper a reference was found to Roseingrave playing an organ concerto with trumpets and kettledrums. This was the reason Peter Holman reconstructed the 'missing' parts.

Thomas Chilcott published two sets of keyboard concertos. The opus 2, of which the concerto on this disc is taken, has been preserved without string parts. For this recording a reconstruction of these parts by Robin Langley has been used.

Often reconstructions are the only way to perform a piece, and sometimes so much material has been left that it is quite possible to make a reconstruction which is stylistically convincing. But when no material has been left at all, like in the concertos by Roseingrave and Chilcott, I am a bit sceptical about the whole process of reconstruction. Any reconstruction is mostly guesswork - "informed guesswork", probably, but still guesswork. That is even more the case with the last concerto on this disc, the Concerto in D by James Hook. It is from his opus 1 which was printed with parts for two violins and bass. Peter Holman writes: "However, there are a number of places in the outer movements of the Hook D major Concerto that seem to call for more varied colours, so I have provided parts for flutes and horns, using as a model the wind parts that survive in manuscript for some of J.C. Bach's Op. 7, or the ad libitum parts for flutes and horns in some of the Philip Hayes concertos". Of course, this is a rather subjective judgement. The same concerto was recorded by David Owen Norris with the ensemble Sonnerie, and never once in that recording did I have the feeling that something was missing.

Don't misunderstand me. I don't want to give the impression that this is a bad recording. Far from it. It is just that I am sceptical about the habit of editing music. There is always the danger that personal taste gets in the way of what the composer has conceived.

That said, this is a most interesting disc which sheds light on a forgotten chapter in English music history. The performances are generally good. Only in the first piece, the Chaconne by Handel, did I find the playing of the ensemble a bit too heavy. The booklet doesn't give a list of players, so I don't know the size of the orchestra, but to me it seemed too large in this particular piece. The second item, a movement for organ and orchestra, is an early version of the first movement from Handel's Organ Concerto Op 7 No 4. Here I would have liked more ornamentation in the solo part.

The use of the the fortepiano in the last two concertos is especially interesting. The earliest English pianos were small squares, the kind of instrument David Owen Norris deployed in his recording. Here another kind of piano is played: a copy of an instrument by Americus Backers from 1770. It is quite different from the continental instruments. Having heard this beautiful example I am inclined to think that it is probably much better suited to the keyboard music of Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach and the early Mozart than the kind of fortepianos mostly used, in particular those by Johann Walter.

Despite my critical remarks there are enough reasons to purchase this disc.

-- Johan van Veen, MusicWeb International
Read less

Works on This Recording

1.
Concerto for Keyboard no 5 in D major by James Hook
Performer:  Paul Nicholson (Harpsichord)
Conductor:  Paul Nicholson
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Parley of Instruments
Period: Classical 
Written: circa 1774; England 
2.
Concerto for Keyboard no 4 in A major by Philip Hayes
Performer:  Paul Nicholson (Harpsichord)
Conductor:  Paul Nicholson
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Parley of Instruments
Period: Classical 
Written: by 1769; England 
3.
These Lessons (5) with a Sonata in Score, Op. 2: no 6, Sonata in G major by James Nares
Performer:  Paul Nicholson (Harpsichord)
Conductor:  Paul Nicholson
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Parley of Instruments
Period: Baroque 
Written: by 1759; England 
4.
Concerto for Harpsichord in A major, Op. 2 no 2 by Thomas Chilcot
Performer:  Paul Nicholson (Harpsichord)
Conductor:  Paul Nicholson
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Parley of Instruments
Period: Classical 
Written: 18th Century; England 
5.
Concerto for Harpsichord in D major by Thomas Roseingrave
Performer:  Paul Nicholson (Harpsichord)
Conductor:  Paul Nicholson
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Parley of Instruments
Period: Baroque 
Written: by 1750; England 
6.
Chaconne and Variations (21) for Harpsichord in G major, HWV 435: Chaconne by George Frideric Handel
Performer:  Paul Nicholson (Harpsichord)
Conductor:  Paul Nicholson
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Parley of Instruments
Period: Baroque 
Written: by 1733; London, England 
7.
Concertos (6) for Organ, Op. 7: no 4 in D minor, HWV 309 - 1st movement, Adagio by George Frideric Handel
Performer:  Paul Nicholson (Harpsichord)
Conductor:  Paul Nicholson
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Parley of Instruments
Period: Baroque 
Written: 1750; London, England 

Customer Reviews

Average Customer Review:  1 Customer Review )
 What have we been missing here? July 15, 2013 By Anthony G. (Valley Stream, NY) See All My Reviews "I bought this CD on a whim as it is a real exotic. And I found it to be exotically ravishing. It has become the cornerstone of my collection of keyboard music. If you are partial to pre-nineteenth century keyboard music, then it is essential that you own this CD. Every listening reveals new beauty and surprises to the ear." Report Abuse
Review This Title
Review This Title Share on Facebook




YOU MUST BE A SUBSCRIBER TO LISTEN - TRY IT FREE!
Listen to all your favorite classical music for only $20/month.
Sign up for your monthly subscription service and get unlimited access to the most comprehensive digital catalog of classical music in the world - new releases. bestsellers, advanced releases and more.
Aleady a subscriber? Sign In