WGBH Radio WGBH Radio theclassicalstation.org

Tchaikovsky: Symphony No 5, Capriccio Italien / Van Kempen

Release Date: 10/15/2008 
Label:  Philips   Catalog #: 420858   Spars Code: n/a 
Composer:  Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Conductor:  Paul Van Kempen
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra
Number of Discs: 1 
Recorded in: Mono 
Length: 0 Hours 57 Mins. 

In Stock: Usually ships in 24 hours.  

This CD is reissued by ArkivMusic.

Notes and Editorial Reviews

Tchaikovsky’s Fifth Symphony - actually his tenth - is the most difficult to conduct, or at least the most difficult of the last three Symphonies. The famous horn solo is obviously a reworked tenor or bass aria from opera sketches, and the seams show. The valse is ballet music. Taneyev was intense in his criticism of the work for this reason. Who knows how Tchaikovsky might have revised this work if he had lived beyond age 53? Van Kempen’s performance of the Fifth Symphony is a fine reading, in the top twenty, but these days you want one with modern sound. But we are all individuals, and my favourite performance of all time is Odd Grüner Hegge conducting the Oslo PO on an old RCA Victrola LP. There will be many people who like this Read more Kempen performance over all others, but they may not know anyone else who does.

This recording of Capriccio Italien is arguable the very best performance ever recorded. Considering how much Tchaikovsky is recorded, it is very unusual for a single recording to be better on every point than others; usually, there is a best slow performance, a best fast performance, a best orchestral balance performance, a best historical performance …. But apart from the mono sound, this recording takes the sweepstakes. I first heard it over local radio, long after it was deleted, and have searched in vain for a copy until now. Bless ArkivCD! They have performed for me the exact service for which they were organized.

Hermann Scherchen gives us more detailed, more realistic mono sound. This recording was a famous HI FI demonstration disk when first released. There’s also a great deal more Russian soul in the slow parts - taking nearly three minutes longer than van Kempen. When the music winds up for the finish it sounds more manic than joyous. Bernstein’s style here fits the music better than usual, and his performance with the NYPO is one of his best Romantic music recordings. Dorati is another good choice for a stereo version but both Bernstein and Dorati have a tendency to rush over subtleties in the race to the finish line, whereas Fiedler is willing and able to slow down briefly to allow a phrase to take a deep breath. All these versions enjoy excellent stereo sound although none of them is exactly new. The Fiedler CD was made from an original direct-to-disc recording instead of a tape; in fact the LP is still available from collectors’ sources. You’ll note that every version I have commented on so far is an analogue master.

Temirkanov offers an excellent 96/24 digital version - which may some day come out on a DVD-Audio - of this same program, with the same depth of Russian soul in the Capriccio Italien that Scherchen offers. His Fifth Symphony is a little on the eccentric side, not far from the Stokowski approach, but very satisfactory overall. However this digital recording will lack the IM distortion, midrange acoustic feedback resonance, transient clipping, attenuated dynamics, pitch instability — oh, excuse me! I mean, of course, “warmth and richness” — that analogue recordings provide.

Some critics complained about audible artefacts of digital noise reduction with the NoNoise system. However if there are any such artefacts here I didn’t notice them while enjoying the music and I have enough experience to know what to listen for. All I noticed was clear sound against a quiet background.

Paul Shoemaker, MusicWeb International
Read less

Works on This Recording

Capriccio italien, Op. 45 by Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Conductor:  Paul Van Kempen
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra
Period: Romantic 
Written: 1880; Russia 
Date of Recording: 1951 
Symphony no 5 in E minor, Op. 64 by Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Conductor:  Paul Van Kempen
Orchestra/Ensemble:  Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra
Period: Romantic 
Written: 1888; Russia 

Customer Reviews

Be the first to review this title
Review This Title